The personal disquiet of

Mark Boulton

March 26th, 2006

Upgrading your mobile phone

{title}It’s that time of year again. Mobile phone upgrade time. 

For the past year I’ve been pretty pleased with my Nokia 6210. Yes, it’s a bit old and clunky and yes, it isn’t sup­por­ted by iSync, but it’s been good to me. How­ever, I’m feel­ing the need to become organ­ised again. I’m also get­ting slightly nervous about rep­lic­a­tion of data on my vari­ous com­puters (work, home, and laptop) and could do with a phone which *is* sup­por­ted by iSync to make things slightly easier.

So, What would you recommend? 

I’ve had prob­lems with Sony Eric­sson before simply because I’ve never really got on with their UI. I’ve almost always used Nokia phones since about 1997, so I’m pretty much insti­tu­tion­al­ised with their oper­at­ing sys­tem. For a while there though, Nokia made dis­gust­ing phones, which is why I switched over the Sonys. One Nokia has caught my eye though: the 6280.

It’s a good look­ing phone. I guess that’s why I like it. And, to boot, it ticks all but one of the checklist:

Which leaves one big, black mark: No iSync support. 

So, what’s a bloke sup­posed to do? Manu­ally do everything? Don’t think so. Has any­one any other sug­ges­tions for a good phone?

27 Responses to “Upgrading your mobile phone”

  1. Virginia said on: March 26th, 2006 at 10:51 pm

    You’re kid­ding — no iSync sup­port? I was ser­i­ously con­sid­er­ing this phone myself, until SXSW ate all my money. My busi­ness part­ner has one, and it’s a beau­ti­ful thing. I just assumed it had sync sup­port. Bah humbug. 

    The Apple for­ums have some tips on how to at least get your con­tacts onto the phone without hav­ing to manu­ally enter them, so that’s something…

  2. Mike D. said on: March 26th, 2006 at 11:10 pm

    If you’re hip on Nokias, the new E70 looks like the dog’s bol­lucks to me. Small, full key­board, wifi, and just about everything else.

  3. Chris Mear said on: March 26th, 2006 at 11:16 pm

    The Nokia 6680 has always worked very well for me with iSync. It’s a bit chunky, though.

  4. Stu Schaff said on: March 26th, 2006 at 11:49 pm

    Is the Motorola Razr sup­por­ted by iSync?  I was told at the Cin­gu­lar store yes­ter­day that of all the phones they offer with bluetooth, it seems to have the best recep­tion as well.  And it’s pretty.

  5. Alexander Hutton said on: March 27th, 2006 at 12:08 am

    iSynch becomes less import­ant if the phone can oper­ate as a modem for EVDO (and you can get flat rate bandwidth). 

    I recently dropped my Treo 650 (bluetooth and Synch­ing) for my beat up old Nokia 3360 — I just have very little use for PDA/Smartphone applic­a­tions — too much laptop, too little need for tiny little applications.

  6. Masklinn said on: March 27th, 2006 at 12:26 am

    I’m not sure that the soon-to-be-released Nokia E70 is com­pat­ible with iSync (you’ll have to check), but it’s the one i’m wait­ing for. Full key­board, WiFi (on top of just about everything else) and Min­iSD cards (which means high capa­cit­ies for very fair prices) are win­ners for me, and the 2MPix cam­era is the icing on the cake. 

    Oh, and the Min­iSD card reader is on top of the bat­tery (and not under it), which means that the memory cards can be hotswapped.

  7. daaku said on: March 27th, 2006 at 4:10 am

    Check out the Nokia N80.

    - WiFi (802.11g!)

    - Bluetooth

    - PDA

    - Syn­cML

    - WebKit/Konqueror based web browser

    - Opera

    - Hi-Res Screen (352x416)

    - 3MP Cam­era + 0.3 Cam­era for 3G Video Calls 

    http://www.nokia.com/n80

    [Talk about SEO’ed URL’s!] 

    No, I dont work for Nokia, just wait­ing to get my hands on this phone myself! (It not very eas­ily available)

  8. Si said on: March 27th, 2006 at 9:30 am

    I can vouch for the N-range of Nokias. I’ve got a N70 which is my life support. 

    I’m not sure if its got iSync sup­port but it does do a sim­ilar job via the Nokia PC suite (obvi­ously no good to you Mac-operators). 

    It is a damned good phone though, even if it is a little on the bulkier side.

  9. Steve Marshall said on: March 27th, 2006 at 9:39 am

    The one big prob­lem with Nokias, for me, is that the Series 40 phones don’t work with iSync, and the Series 60 phones are Symbian-based, and are there­fore remark­able more for the fact that they’re slow as hell and unstable than any­thing else. That, and Series 60 gen­er­ally is far, far too cluttered (due to being a smart­phone OS). 

    Gen­er­ally, Series 40 phones have good levels of usab­il­ity, at a sim­ilar level to the Sony Eric­sson (non-UIQ) phones. What I can say, though, is that Sony Eric­sson non-UIQ phones tend to have more fea­tures, bet­ter real­ised, and at bet­ter price-points than Nokia. 

    If you’re look­ing at smart­phones, I wouldn’t even bother look­ing at Nokia: their ver­sion of Sym­bian is renowned for being slow, unstable, and gen­er­ally not very intuitive. 

    Per­son­ally, as much as I like the looks of some of the Nokia phones (the N-series, for example, and the 72xx series), all the phones that appeal to me either don’t have the fea­tures I need (iSync sup­port, et al.) or use Symbian. 

    Dis­claimer: I’ve used mostly SE phones for the last few years, save a Motorola Razr (which was really sexy, but utterly, utterly shite).

  10. Mark Boulton said on: March 27th, 2006 at 11:51 am

    Ok, well it looks like I can’t actu­ally upgrade until August, which leaves me a while to do the research into the best option.

    I’m prob­ably still going to go for the Nokia, des­pite the lack of iSync sup­port. I’m just not into car­ry­ing around a bulky device that can do everything. Maybe in six months time either Nokia or Apple will sort them­selves out and sup­port each other. I won’t hold my breath though.

  11. neoguri said on: March 27th, 2006 at 12:57 pm

    Apple seems plain lazy when it comes to adding iSync sup­port. Luck­ily oth­ers can do the work Apple lacks in. This guy is col­lect­ing info and suc­ces stor­ies of DIY iSync scripts. 

    On Nokia phones:

    < blockquote>Positive feed­back so far: Nokia N70, N71, N80, N90, N91, N92, E60, E61, 6680, 6630, 7710, 9300, 9500

    Neg­at­ive: Nokia all Series 40 phones, 6021, 6230, 6255, 8800, 8801</blockquote>

  12. Jason Santa Maria said on: March 27th, 2006 at 1:41 pm

    I just bought an unlocked Motorola SLVR and it ful­fills all of your require­ments (which were the same ones I had too), includ­ing iSync support.

  13. Les said on: March 27th, 2006 at 3:25 pm

    They’re not Nokias but they might be around when you renew: new Sony Eric­ssons were shown at CeBIT 2006 

    http://www.sonyericsson.com/cebit/flash.html

  14. Ryan said on: March 28th, 2006 at 12:38 am

    I’ve been look­ing at these: 

    Motorolla Razr V3

    Motorolla Slvr S7

    BenQ-Siemens EF81 

    I think they all fit the bill.  The EF81 looks beau­ti­ful to my eye. 

    How­ever, those pesky iPhone rumours have sur­faced again, this time int he form or an iPod with phone fea­tures. Con­sid­er­ing I don’t do any­thing with my phone except make calls, txt people and sync my address book, I’ll wait a couple of months then buy whatever is the best at the time.

    :)

  15. *helmen said on: March 28th, 2006 at 12:47 am

    I have some exper­i­ence with Nokia and Motorola, but I can recom­mend only Sony Eric­sson phones. Now I have Sony Eric­sson K750i and Power­Book. I’m syn­chron­iz­ing my phone (cal­en­dar, to-do, phone­book) with my Power­Book every day without any problems. 

    I’m using my K750i like a phone, organ­izer, MP3 player and digital camera. 

    My Most using Apps:

    - Opera Mini (web browser)

    - IM+ (Instant Mes­sen­ger)

    - Maps

    - Salling Clicker (remote con­trol)

    - Dic­tion­ary

    - RSS Reader 

    K750i

    - Dimen­sions: 100 x 46 x 20.5 mm

    - Weight: 99 g

    - Looks good

    - Syn­cML

    - Bluetooth 2.0

    - 2MP Camera 

    You can read some more inform­a­tions and check apps for K750i on my blog.

    Here you can watch my phtos from Sony Eric­sson K750i.

  16. Aaron said on: March 28th, 2006 at 9:47 pm

    I’d give my vote to the Sony Eric­sson as well. Maybe the UI has been updated since you used it, because I find mine to be a lot faster and intu­it­ive than any phone I’ve used. I use a W600, and while it doesn’t work with iSync in OSX 10.3, it’s sup­posed to be sup­por­ted in 10.4. I can also use it to check e-mail, which is very handy. The built in iTunes-esque music player is great for occas­sions when your iPod is unavail­able (or dead).

  17. The Gimp said on: March 28th, 2006 at 9:49 pm

    I just pur­chased a RAZR from Ver­i­zon which didn’t sup­port iSync. Hack­ing the plist file to duplic­ate a phone that I knew worked even­tu­ally got iSync work­ing for me. You might be able to do the same with the Nokia. I’ll check out the plist file for phone sup­port and post if I fig­ure any­thing out.

  18. Mark Boulton said on: March 29th, 2006 at 10:53 am

    Aaron: I’m ser­i­ously con­sid­er­ing the Sony Eric­sson. It’s not too bad and the iSync sup­port may well clinch the deal. Like I said though, I’ve got another six months to make up my mind, so no ini­tial rush.

    I just wish Nokia and Apple would sort them­selves out. If Nokia are going to con­tinue releas­ing series 60 phones, why can’t Apple sup­port them? I’m sure there’s a very good reason why not, and it’s prob­ably due to Nokia’s inab­il­ity to sup­port open formats, it just pains me that I have to switch from an oper­at­ing sys­tem I’m not used to. 

    I don’t like change.

  19. Graham Sanders said on: March 30th, 2006 at 10:53 pm

    Hi Mark

    For what it’s worth I upgraded my phone recently from a Sony Eric­sson S700i to a Sony Eric­sson K750i and boy oh boy am I am happy bunny. It ticks all your list and adds some more: http://tinyurl.com/55g58

    iSync

    Bluetooth

    FM radio

    Cam­era 2 mega­pixel

    Video Recorder

    Photo Light

    Music Player (you can make your own mp3 playl­ists)

    Memory Stick PRO Duo? (comes with 64mb card)

    Speaker phone (use­ful for con­fer­ence calls)

    Fit in back pocket

    Looks very, very good

    Small and light

    Makes phone calls as well which is always useful :) 

    Think I missed my voca­tion in life as a Sony salesman. 

    Oh and before i for­get I sold my pre­vi­ous Sony Eric­sson S700i on ebay for ?100 which has nicely paid for 3 months usage. 

    This HAS to be a winner!!!

  20. Ryan said on: March 31st, 2006 at 1:01 am

    Any­one have any exper­i­ence with the Motorola SLVR and iSync etc? 

    PS. Your com­ment fom requires an email address, but doesn’t flag the field with a ?. 

    :)

  21. David Hughes said on: March 31st, 2006 at 10:51 am

    I have a K750i and really like it.  Works very well with the Mac — SE still have the best Bluetooth implementation. 

    If you are wait­ing until August then the K800i will be avail­able — the 3G ver­sion of teh K750i with a 3.2mp camera! 

    Looks lovely! 

    http://www.sonyericsson.com/spg.jsp?cc=global&lc=en&ver=4001&template=pp1_1_1&zone=pp&lm=pp1&pid=10407

    David

  22. Chris Mear said on: April 4th, 2006 at 12:02 am

    News­flash: OS X 10.4.6 update adds Nokia 6280 iSync support. 

    http://www.apple.com/macosx/features/isync/devices.html

  23. Ivan Brezak Brkan said on: April 4th, 2006 at 11:04 am

    I would strongly recom­mend get­ting a Sony Eric­sson phone because of its soft­ware which is prob­ably the most intu­it­ive on any mobile phone, and sup­ports applic­a­tions like Salling Clicker and Blue Phole Elite! I just bought a SE K750i and I couldn’t be hap­pier… I ticks all of your wishes includ­ing iSync sup­port. It would be the ulti­mate phone if the feel of it was more metalic (some­thing like the Motorola L7, which has ter­rible soft­ware), but thats just me. The cam­era is one of the best I’ve seen. You should check out GSMarena.com and Mobile-review.com for some mobile phone reviews! I do recom­mend the K750i… Its sexy, yet “smart” too! ;)

  24. Robert Nicholson said on: April 5th, 2006 at 6:30 pm

    I have an N80 and I can tell you that I don’t think it’s sup­por­ted by iSync because Apple hasn’t signed their sync cli­ent yet and you can­not install unsigned apps on an Series 60 3rd gen device like the N80. If any­body has got­ten the N80 work­ing with iSync I’d sure love to hear about it.

  25. hbielen said on: April 6th, 2006 at 11:07 am

    soon you’ll be able to install Win­dows on your Mac (http://www.apple.com/macosx/bootcamp/)and then you’ll be able to instal the Nokia PC suite on it. Maybe?

  26. Virginia said on: April 6th, 2006 at 11:48 pm

    Did you see? 10.4.6 updated the list of com­pat­ible devices for iSync, and the 6820 is on it. Weeeee!

  27. Mike Stenhouse said on: April 7th, 2006 at 7:04 pm

    I just ordered myself a Treo 650… Aging a little now but it’s my first toe in the smart phone pool. I want IMAP email, Opera Mini and a decent screen. That’s it. I’ll report back!

  • Me

    Hello. My name is Mark Boulton. I’m a designer, an author, a speaker and I run a small design agency where we work with lovely cli­ents and pub­lish books as we go. This is my blog.

  • More of me

  • Publications

    Design­ing for the Web
    Start­ing from £19 + VAT for a PDF Down­load. £29 for a full col­our paperback.
  • Where I work

    Mark Boulton Design
    A small design stu­dio doing good things for nice clients.
    Five Simple Steps
    Pub­lish­ing easy to read design books.
  • See me speak

    @Media 2010
    June 8th — 11th, Lon­don, UK.
    Drupal­Con 2010
    August 23th — 27th, Copen­ha­gen, Denmark.
    dCon­struct 2010: Design 1010 workshop
    Septem­ber 1st, Brighton, UK.
    Web­d­a­gene
    Septem­ber 29th — Octo­ber 1st, Oslo, Norway
    Web Developers Conference
    Octo­ber 27th, Bris­tol, UK.
    New Adven­tures in Web Design
    Janu­ary 20th 2011, Not­ting­ham, UK.
  • Copyright © 1999–2010 Mark Boulton. Made with an Apple Mac in Wales. Running on WordPress and VPS.net.